We back the plan. We'd change five things.
- Fix conversion before spending. Ads stay off until the February relaunch.
- Regional first. Newcastle turns ad clicks into leads 4x better than Neutral Bay.
- Gum disease is the core. Always on, two messages tested.
- Lip repositioning as a two month Meta pilot.
- One shared dashboard, from ad click to treatment.
- Re-base the targets. The deck's baselines still count phone taps. The lead definition we agreed on 6 November doesn't.
- Start the clock at relaunch. Ad numbers can't move while ads are off. The next 90 days are the build.
- Fewer, bigger tests. A $500 line is too small to read.
- Receding gums from day one, implants in months 3 and 4.
- Give paid its own cost per consult. The $467 in the deck is carried by dentist referrals.
Same data. Two definitions.
The deck's 3.5%, 3.1% and $286 count every phone tap. Since 6 November a lead is a form, an email, a Meta form or a chat with contact details. On that count the starting line moves.
| Measure | Deck baseline | Agreed definition | Deck target | Day 90 | Month 6 | Month 12 | Our read |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Google click to lead | 3.5% | 1.5% | 5 to 7% | 4% | 5% | 6%+ | Re-base5% by month 6. 7% is a Newcastle stretch. |
| Google cost per lead | $286 | $661 | $250 | $400 | $320 | $250 to $270 | Re-base$250 is reachable as a 12 month goal. |
| Cost per booked consult, ads only | $467all sources | $1,090+not tracked yet | $350 | $1,100 | $750 | $550 | New lineKeep $350 as the whole-business number. |
| Meta cost per booked consult | 1 booking from 49 leads | $3,300 | None set | Under $800 | Under $650 | Under $500 | New lineJudge Meta on bookings, not form fills. |
| Enquiry to consultclinic led | 38% | 29%patient enquiries | 50% | 35 to 40% | 45% | 50% | Back itDentist enquiries already book at 50%. |
| Website visitor to enquiryDylan's plan | 3.1% | 1.5% | 5% | Set in Dylan's website plan | Re-baseSame phone tap effect. | ||
Day 90, month 6 and month 12 count from the relaunch. Leads include online bookings. Purple columns are what we expect and will report against.
Option A. Keep the agreed definition.
Re-base the targets to the purple columns. Bookings count. Real phone calls get their own line, tracked but separate.
Option B. Keep 5 to 7% as written.
Then phone taps count again. The regional mix lands near 7% from month one, but the number says less about real patients.
$250 a lead and 7% are the same goal.
Moving budget to the regions raises the cost of a click, so the lead rate has to do the work. That is the landing pages.
Newcastle wins on ad leads. Not on bookings.
Small numbers in the regions: 12 and 5 leads in a year. A direction, not proof yet.
Our reading of your appendix. Newcastle's 44% comes from its dentist network. Its patient enquiries book at 24%, close to Neutral Bay.
| Clinic | Google spend | Clicks | Leads | Click to lead | Cost per lead | Any enquiry action | Patient enquiry to consult |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Neutral Bay | $23,970 | 2,687 | 31 | 1.15% | $773 | 2.6% | 21% |
| Newcastle | $3,416 | 255 | 12 | 4.7% | $285 | 10.6% | 24% |
| Kiama | $4,348 | 227 | 5 | 2.2% | $870 | 6.6% | 46% |
| All three | $31,734 | 3,169 | 48 | 1.5% | $661 | 3.5% | 29% |
Newcastle needs the follow-up fix too
Cheaper leads are the case for Newcastle. The booking rate on patient enquiries is not there yet.
Kiama patients phone
6.6% of ad clicks made contact, but only 2.2% used a form. Real calls deserve their own line.
Neutral Bay had 75% of spend
And the lowest lead rate. Holding it back until the process is fixed is the right call.
The regions are small. Scale lives in Sydney.
Google keyword planner estimates, checked November 2026. City level, main terms only. Surrounding suburbs add a little.
| Searches a month | Sydney | Newcastle | Illawarra |
|---|---|---|---|
| Periodontist | 2,540 | 150 | 90 |
| Gum disease | 3,380 | 150 | 130 |
| Receding gums, gum grafting | 2,170 | 110 | 70 |
| Dental implants | 4,380 | 210 | 130 |
| Gummy smile, lip repositioning | 540 | 30 | 30 |
| Total | 13,010 | 650 | 450 |
Same $4,500. Fewer, bigger tests.
A search test needs about 150 clicks to read. A Meta pilot needs about 20 screened leads. $500 a month on implants buys about 30 clicks.
Months 1 and 2
Months 3 and 4
Both splits total $4,500 a month. If the lip pilot passes its mark it keeps running, and we show you the trade-off at the day 60 review.
Months 3 and 4, at $750. The last implants test got about 1 lead from 130 clicks. The page comes first.
From day one, as a message. About 110 Newcastle searches a month can't spend $500 on its own.
On hold. Clicks cost $25 to $39 there. $500 buys 13 to 20 of them.
Sydney weighted. 9 in 10 of those searches are in Sydney. If Neutral Bay isn't ready, we hold it.
What $4,500 a month should buy by day 90
Estimates from your own account history, not guarantees. More budget does not fix the lead rate, and the regions cannot absorb much more.
Budget steps up when the numbers earn it
Regional first. Prove the pages and the follow-up.
Gate: click to lead 4%+ and enquiry to consult 40%+, two months running. The extra goes to Sydney.
Gate: 5%+ and 45%+, two months running. At these rates: about 20 leads and 10 booked consults a month.
Six campaigns. Each with a pass mark.
Protect the Core
Find a Periodontist
Gum Health on Meta
Love Your Lips
Newcastle Implants
Save Your Gums
Your campaigns 1, 2, 5 and 6 (follow-up, website, dentist partners, existing patients) are clinic and website led. Our part in each is in section 08.
Chasing the leads that didn't book.
Google retargeting
Google does not allow remarketing or customer lists for health treatments. So "Meta first, then retarget on Google" becomes: Meta creates the interest, Google Search catches the people who then go looking.
Meta retargeting
People who watched a video, opened a form or engaged with the page. Website visitor audiences may be limited by Meta's health rules. We'll confirm on your account. No patient lists are uploaded.
SMS and email follow-up
The real fix. A reply inside 5 minutes, then about 10 touches over 3 weeks: 3 calls, SMS, emails. Every lead ends with an outcome. We can build it. It sits outside the ads work, so we'd scope it with you.
- Two step forms. Name and mobile first, which is the lead. Screening questions second, so the lead rate holds.
- Screening questions on Meta forms. Fewer leads, more of them real.
- The chat assistant answers at night, when 55% of Meta leads arrive, and collects contact details.
- Ads to your dentist list won't run. The list is too small for Meta, Google or LinkedIn to match.
- What works: a reactivation email sequence for lapsed referrers, and referral forms tracked by referrer.
- Clinic led. We can support the digital pieces if you want them scoped.
Everything from the session. One line each.
90 days to build. 12 months to prove it.
Fix and build
- Tracking rebuilt on the agreed definition
- Treatment by location pages, with Dylan
- Campaigns, forms and chat assistant built
- Creative briefed and compliance checked
- Dashboard and D4W source field
Relaunch and test
- Core live in Newcastle and Kiama
- Meta gum health and the lip pilot
- Lip pilot decision at day 60
- Implants test starts in April
Scale what proved it
- Implants result in
- Winners take the budget
- Neutral Bay back in, once ready
- Step to $6,500 if the gate is met
Expand
- Winning campaigns roll out to the other clinics
- Sydney carries the growth
- Step to $8,000 if the gate is met
Review
- 12 month review against this page
- Year two plan and targets
One dashboard. Two sets of inputs.
Monthly. Split by clinic, treatment and channel, with digital and dental kept apart. Every lead carries its source so D4W can be matched back.
| Stage | What we report | Who supplies it | Who owns the result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Attract | Spend, clicks, cost per click | Uppercut, from Google Ads and Meta | Uppercut |
| Convert | Leads, bookings, click to lead, cost per lead. Calls on their own line. | Uppercut, from Google Ads, Meta and GA4 | Uppercut, pages with Dylan |
| Book | Enquiry to consult, cost per booked consult | Clinic, from the D4W source field | Clinic, we support |
| Treat | Consult to treatment, cost per treatment | Clinic, from D4W | Clinic |